Is Amy Brenneman A-List?
No — Amy Brenneman is currently ranked B tier — a well-known figure with a strong career but not quite a household name.
Reached A-list in 1999
Judging Amy Creation and Star
Lost A-list status in 2005
Dropped to B tier — Judging Amy Ends
Ranking Timeline
Early TV Roles
Brenneman takes on various small roles in TV series and movies, building experience.
NYPD Blue Breakthrough
Her role as Detective Janice Licalsi in *NYPD Blue* brings her critical acclaim and raises her profile.
Judging Amy Creation and Star
Brenneman co-creates and stars in *Judging Amy*, a successful CBS drama.
Judging Amy Ends
After six seasons, *Judging Amy* ends; Brenneman's career maintains steady work.
The Leftovers
Starred in HBO's The Leftovers which was a success, adding to her popularity.
Shining Vale Lead Role
Stars in the comedy horror television series, Shining Vale, which keeps her a working actor.
Consistent Television Presence
Brenneman continues to work steadily in television, maintaining a respected career.
Last updated: February 25, 2026