Is Benni McCarthy A-List?
No — Benni McCarthy is currently ranked B tier — a well-known figure with a strong career but not quite a household name.
Reached A-list in 2004
Champions League Winner
Lost A-list status in 2010
Dropped to B tier — West Ham United
Ranking Timeline
Ajax Transfer
Moves to Ajax in the Netherlands, gaining international exposure.
Champions League Winner
Wins the UEFA Champions League with Porto under José Mourinho.
Blackburn Rovers Move
Joins Blackburn Rovers, becoming a fan favorite in the Premier League.
West Ham United
Brief stint with West Ham United.
Retirement
Retires from professional football.
Coaching Career Begins
Starts his coaching career in South Africa.
Kenya National Team Manager
Appointed as the manager of the Kenya national football team.
Continued Coaching Success
Continues to manage the Kenya national team, solidifying his reputation as a capable coach.
Last updated: February 23, 2026