Is David de Gea A-List?
No — David de Gea is currently ranked B tier — a well-known figure with a strong career but not quite a household name.
Reached A-list in 2017
Peak Performance Years
Lost A-list status in 2022
Dropped to B tier — Decline and Contract Issues
Ranking Timeline
Atlético Madrid Emergence
De Gea breaks into Atlético Madrid's first team as a teenager, quickly establishing himself as one of Spain's most promising goalkeepers. His performances attract interest from top European clubs.
Manchester United Transfer
Joins Manchester United for £18.9 million as replacement for the legendary Edwin van der Sar. Initial struggles in the physical Premier League lead to criticism, but his talent is undeniable.
Establishes Himself at United
De Gea's exceptional performances earn him the club's Player of the Year award, silencing early critics. He becomes recognized as one of the Premier League's best goalkeepers.
Peak Performance Years
Wins multiple Player of the Year awards and establishes himself as arguably the world's best goalkeeper. His spectacular saves often single-handedly earn United points, making him invaluable to the club.
World Cup Disappointment
Loses Spain's starting spot to Chelsea's Kepa during the World Cup, marking a setback in his international career. Despite club success, he struggles to cement his place as Spain's number one.
Decline and Contract Issues
De Gea's form dips with several high-profile errors, and contract negotiations with Manchester United stall. His status as an elite goalkeeper comes into question as younger talents emerge.
Manchester United Departure
Leaves Manchester United after 12 years when contract talks break down. Despite being a club legend with over 500 appearances, his departure is relatively low-key, and he spends months without a club.
Fiorentina Fresh Start
Joins Fiorentina in Serie A as captain, seeking to rebuild his career in Italy. While still a quality goalkeeper, his best years are clearly behind him.
Solid Veteran Goalkeeper
De Gea continues as Fiorentina's captain and remains a reliable goalkeeper in Serie A. Once considered one of the world's best, he is now regarded as a respected veteran with a strong career at Manchester United behind him, well-known in football circles but past his peak years.
Last updated: February 25, 2026