Is Melissa Benoist A-List?
No — Melissa Benoist is currently ranked B tier — a well-known figure with a strong career but not quite a household name.
Ranking Timeline
Glee Debut as Marley
Melissa joins Glee as Marley Rose, gaining initial recognition and increasing her visibility.
Cast as Supergirl
Melissa is cast as Supergirl, a breakthrough role that elevates her career and net worth.
Supergirl Crossover Success
Supergirl achieves crossover success, further solidifying Melissa's position in the superhero genre.
Broadway Debut
Melissa makes her Broadway debut, showcasing her versatility and talent on the stage.
Supergirl Series Finale
Supergirl concludes its run, marking the end of a significant chapter in Melissa's career.
Continuing TV and Film Roles
Melissa continues to work in TV and film, maintaining a successful career as a versatile actress.
Last updated: February 25, 2026